And I should believe this distortion spec discussion because? (warning: I am a highly experienced electronic engineer with lengthy generator/inverter experience).If you’re hotting up the house:
The Firman is 30% harmonic distortion.
You want 1.5% to 3% max., preferably 1.5% or less.
Everything in your home is circuit boarded from your forced air heat to computers and so forth.
Above 3% will mess ‘um up.
Also it is louder than the Sledge Hammers of hell.
I really wanted this generator. Just easily pipe it to the home gas,, good to go. Just like hooking up a new cloths dryer even easier.
But the potential to wipe out the board on $3k fridge we went inverter.
And I should believe this distortion spec discussion because? (warning: I am a highly experienced electronic engineer with lengthy generator/inverter experience).
The owner of this brand was camping with us this weekend. Good dude. Don't know much about the gen but Jason was very nice guy.
So, I have an older stationary propane generator that needs some love. It is a trailer mounted 15kw unit and am considering setting it up for backup use. It hasn't been started in 15 years or better but ran well when parked. I can make it run but the real question is the harmonic distortion. It is old enough I am not going to be able to look it up. Any way to test this? I would love to know if it is worth putting time and energy into it. I could buy something new but this is already paid for and reasonably sized for my house, and well.
Thoughts anyone?
Dual Fuel Portable Generator 7500W Electric Start 120/240V
At FIRMAN, we are combining quality with dual-fuel flexibility. The FIRMAN H07552 Hybrid portable dual fuel generator running off Gasoline or Propane could be the perfect solution. Offering up to 9400 Starting watts and 7500 Running watts, this 459cc powerhouse provides great power with an...www.firmanpowerequipment.com
According to their website its "25" guessing thats 25% on full load.
If thats right it's terrible.
What generator did he have lolThe owner of this brand was camping with us this weekend. Good dude. Don't know much about the gen but Jason was very nice guy.
What generator did he have lol
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
And I should believe this distortion spec discussion because? (warning: I am a highly experienced electronic engineer with lengthy generator/inverter experience).
On a separate subject have had awesome performance from Kubota diesel generators for over 13 years. Warning: not cheap to buy but cheap to own.
THD to a large degree depends on the nature of the load. If it's purely resistive, then most any generator can furnish a very low THD %, but you won't find that in modern homes. What we don't know is the testing parameters used to determine that. I'd certainly be hesitant to use it on anything I was fond of with micro-processors.
So I believe what the obtuse and relatively useless post by Pesky Varmint was hinting at was, well, fuck if I know, but he's an expert, who just wanted to blow his own horn and leave us all envious we're not him.
Lol. His Brand. Another guy had one too. Was quiet and seemed like a nice product
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Fridges/ freezers, AC units and air compressors will put a good hurt on THD, Hard to start, and possessing variable resistance mid cycle you can get a good idea plugging in these and watching your sine wave "fuzz"
Whereas a heat gun or hair dryer is much easier on it.
I have been reading every thread on generators when they POP up. I am so suprised with as very Important Emergency power is to most in here, I believe Safe, Reliable and a "Done Deal" that you guys are messing around with IMO "Toys" Back in the Midwest wher I am from, People have a Generac or ? built/wired in and it is such a No Worry and Professional Choice that I feel is worth every $1.00 they Cost. They start when ever programmed to always be 'On Call" ready in case of an Emergency. They are professionally Wired in and a One Stop, Forget it Purchase.
I bet he still has a honda 2000....I just camped with the owner of Forman generators.. The guys bane is Jason (back right if this pic) super nice guy.. I was going to talk to him about a generator solution fir this vending trailer I am buying View attachment 952194
Well said.THD to a large degree depends on the nature of the load. If it's purely resistive, then most any generator can furnish a very low THD %, but you won't find that in modern homes. What we don't know is the testing parameters used to determine that. I'd certainly be hesitant to use it on anything I was fond of with micro-processors.
So I believe what the obtuse and relatively useless post by Pesky Varmint was hinting at was, well, fuck if I know, but he's an expert, who just wanted to blow his own horn and leave us all envious we're not him.
THD to a large degree depends on the nature of the load. If it's purely resistive, then most any generator can furnish a very low THD %, but you won't find that in modern homes. What we don't know is the testing parameters used to determine that. I'd certainly be hesitant to use it on anything I was fond of with micro-processors.
So I believe what the obtuse and relatively useless post by Pesky Varmint was hinting at was, well, fuck if I know, but he's an expert, who just wanted to blow his own horn and leave us all envious we're not him.
I've personally had three quality Kubota generators operating for over 14 years on all manner of electronic/electrical devices in my house (which by the way is off-grid solar so it's inverters when it's not generators). Keep in mind the large numbers of RV's equipped with generators that over the years have successfully and reliably run a host of devices. PC boards don't define a vulnerable device. And generators are close enough as far as the sine wave quality that other more mundane difficulties such as voltage surges are likely to cause failures. And surges occur regardless of source as they are related to length of feed, current draw, and power interruption (inductive kickback).THD to a large degree depends on the nature of the load. If it's purely resistive, then most any generator can furnish a very low THD %, but you won't find that in modern homes. What we don't know is the testing parameters used to determine that. I'd certainly be hesitant to use it on anything I was fond of with micro-processors.
So I believe what the obtuse and relatively useless post by Pesky Varmint was hinting at was, well, fuck if I know, but he's an expert, who just wanted to blow his own horn and leave us all envious we're not him.
I've personally had three quality Kubota generators operating for over 14 years on all manner of electronic/electrical devices in my house (which by the way is off-grid solar so it's inverters when it's not generators). Keep in mind the large numbers of RV's equipped with generators that over the years have successfully and reliably run a host of devices. PC boards don't define a vulnerable device. And generators are close enough as far as the sine wave quality that other more mundane difficulties such as voltage surges are likely to cause failures. And surges occur regardless of source as they are related to length of feed, current draw, and power interruption (inductive kickback).
Generators are very unlikely to hurt anything unless they have garbage voltage regulation (read: "made in china"). I also own 3 Onan generators are pretty reliable but getting parts is more difficult than the Kubota because most Onan dealers are "old school". Also bought a Generac 5000 watt diesel in 2015, had a Yanmar engine (that was reliable in some other generators I've had) but the engine crapped out in a year. Anytime you need anything for a Generac it's "see your dealer". Can't go online and find stuff. In other words tough to get parts for.
No, the problem is not generator distortion. My favorite RV related electrical problem is "modified sine wave" inverters. Many power tool battery chargers get destroyed by those inverters since their waveform is a square wave, and the chargers drop the incoming voltage using a capacitor (the explanation would be very lengthy). Another inverter problem, possibly applying to inverter generators, is if the output transistors fail. A good inverter is very heavy because it includes a transformer. There are many transformerless inverters. On the transformerless inverters (such as may inverter generators are), if the output transistor fails shorted it puts 150 volds DC on your power line which can destroy a lot of things. Been there, done that. It is possible to build a transformerless inverter that in the event of this type of failure will disconnect, but I haven't taken the time to research the market (yet). I've always bought transformer inverters with sine wave outputs. I suspect inverter generators from a reputable company such as Onan would be engineered correctly, but haven't dug into it.
Don't get me started on brush vs. brushless generators, straight rotor vs. twisted rotor and what that has to do with distortion. And other subjects like problems with 220 volt outputs used for 110, and causes of stator failure. Suffice to say that inverter generators are the wave of the future for a lot of mechanical as well as electrical reasons.
In summary, my personal experience (and I have no shortage of devices like computers, big screen TV's, surround sound, a complete electronic lab, and you can't hardly buy any electrical device now that doesn't have some PC board and have not had any failures (other than the stupid malfunctions inevitable in cheap Chinese electronic devices). I think IEEE is a bit demanding in their spec recommendation but that's how people have to be when they publish stuff, especially standards, in our highly litigious age. And it is not just my personal experience I provide informal support to a number of people in my area with off grid solar and generator back ups.
I've personally had three quality Kubota generators operating for over 14 years on all manner of electronic/electrical devices in my house (which by the way is off-grid solar so it's inverters when it's not generators). Keep in mind the large numbers of RV's equipped with generators that over the years have successfully and reliably run a host of devices. PC boards don't define a vulnerable device. And generators are close enough as far as the sine wave quality that other more mundane difficulties such as voltage surges are likely to cause failures. And surges occur regardless of source as they are related to length of feed, current draw, and power interruption (inductive kickback).
Generators are very unlikely to hurt anything unless they have garbage voltage regulation (read: "made in china"). I also own 3 Onan generators are pretty reliable but getting parts is more difficult than the Kubota because most Onan dealers are "old school". Also bought a Generac 5000 watt diesel in 2015, had a Yanmar engine (that was reliable in some other generators I've had) but the engine crapped out in a year. Anytime you need anything for a Generac it's "see your dealer". Can't go online and find stuff. In other words tough to get parts for.
No, the problem is not generator distortion. My favorite RV related electrical problem is "modified sine wave" inverters. Many power tool battery chargers get destroyed by those inverters since their waveform is a square wave, and the chargers drop the incoming voltage using a capacitor (the explanation would be very lengthy). Another inverter problem, possibly applying to inverter generators, is if the output transistors fail. A good inverter is very heavy because it includes a transformer. There are many transformerless inverters. On the transformerless inverters (such as many inverter generators are), if the output transistor fails shorted it puts 150 volds DC on your power line which can destroy a lot of things. Been there, done that. It is possible to build a transformerless inverter that in the event of this type of failure will disconnect, but I haven't taken the time to research the market (yet). I've always bought transformer inverters with sine wave outputs. I suspect inverter generators from a reputable company such as Onan would be engineered correctly, but haven't dug into it.
Don't get me started on brush vs. brushless generators, straight rotor vs. twisted rotor and what that has to do with distortion. And other subjects like problems with 220 volt outputs used for 110, and causes of stator failure. Suffice to say that inverter generators are the wave of the future for a lot of mechanical as well as electrical reasons.
In summary, my personal experience (and I have no shortage of devices like computers, big screen TV's, surround sound, a complete electronic lab, and you can't hardly buy any electrical device now that doesn't have some PC board and have not had any failures (other than the stupid malfunctions inevitable in cheap Chinese electronic devices). I think IEEE is a bit demanding in their spec recommendation but that's how people have to be when they publish stuff, especially standards, in our highly litigious age. And it is not just my personal experience I provide informal support to a number of people in my area with off grid solar and generator back ups.
The vision of hell I imagine for myself would be sitting between you and YumaRiverNaut on a 6 hours Spirit Airlines flight.
I've personally had three quality Kubota generators operating for over 14 years on all manner of electronic/electrical devices in my house (which by the way is off-grid solar so it's inverters when it's not generators). Keep in mind the large numbers of RV's equipped with generators that over the years have successfully and reliably run a host of devices. PC boards don't define a vulnerable device. And generators are close enough as far as the sine wave quality that other more mundane difficulties such as voltage surges are likely to cause failures. And surges occur regardless of source as they are related to length of feed, current draw, and power interruption (inductive kickback).
Generators are very unlikely to hurt anything unless they have garbage voltage regulation (read: "made in china"). I also own 3 Onan generators are pretty reliable but getting parts is more difficult than the Kubota because most Onan dealers are "old school". Also bought a Generac 5000 watt diesel in 2015, had a Yanmar engine (that was reliable in some other generators I've had) but the engine crapped out in a year. Anytime you need anything for a Generac it's "see your dealer". Can't go online and find stuff. In other words tough to get parts for.
No, the problem is not generator distortion. My favorite RV related electrical problem is "modified sine wave" inverters. Many power tool battery chargers get destroyed by those inverters since their waveform is a square wave, and the chargers drop the incoming voltage using a capacitor (the explanation would be very lengthy). Another inverter problem, possibly applying to inverter generators, is if the output transistors fail. A good inverter is very heavy because it includes a transformer. There are many transformerless inverters. On the transformerless inverters (such as many inverter generators are), if the output transistor fails shorted it puts 150 volds DC on your power line which can destroy a lot of things. Been there, done that. It is possible to build a transformerless inverter that in the event of this type of failure will disconnect, but I haven't taken the time to research the market (yet). I've always bought transformer inverters with sine wave outputs. I suspect inverter generators from a reputable company such as Onan would be engineered correctly, but haven't dug into it.
I just camped with the owner of Forman generators.. The guys bane is Jason (back right if this pic) super nice guy.. I was going to talk to him about a generator solution fir this vending trailer I am buying