SamMaxco
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2020
- Messages
- 113
- Reaction score
- 64
Has anyone with a Hallett 210 or similar tried a Hill 5 blade SS prop vs 4 blade merc rev 4
Looking for anyone’s experiences.
Looking for anyone’s experiences.
Has anyone with a Hallett 210 or similar tried a Hill 5 blade SS prop vs 4 blade merc rev 4
Looking for anyone’s experiences.
Im looking for a bit more bottom end bite for pulling my 250lb butt up and out of the water faster. At the same time NOT losing any cruise or top speed. I would like to get from 4900 rpm up to 5200 at wot - and see if I can maintain or gain top speed while have more snap or bite out of the hole pulling myself out on a single ski. Basically I want the perfect prop, not asking for much .I had one of there pleasure 5’s on a 28 eagle. Was an all around good prop. Good hole shot and cruise speed. Not an aggressive bite. Not sure what your looking for the prop to do im not sure how to recommend. I had a cutting edge 5 blade after that and it was a touch better but that was on a different boat.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Im looking for a bit more bottom end bite for pulling my 250lb butt up and out of the water faster. At the same time NOT losing any cruise or top speed. I would like to get from 4900 rpm up to 5200 at wot - and see if I can maintain or gain top speed while have more snap or bite out of the hole pulling myself out on a single ski. Basically I want the perfect prop, not asking for much [emoji23].
my two thoughts are drop down to a rev 4 21 pitch and maybe have it worked, if that even necessary, maybe it’s fine stock, which should do the job, or try the Hill 5 blade 21 pitch, which I’m told will do just that, I have no experience with Hill 5 blade, but I know they’re very reputable and stand behind their stuff. I really like the Rev 4 23 p that is on it, all around, it’s not bad, I tried a B1 22p did not like at all, the rev 4 23 was better everywhere. I’m just trying to see if I can get a bit more ski pulling power off the very bottom without losing my cruise or top speed. I have a merc racing blue scorpion 377 - I know it would like to be around 5200 more than it likes 4800-4900 rpm. I’m will to spend 1000 bucks to see if I can gain a bit more bottom and top.
To those that know, am I being unrealistic?
Thank you. In in Visalia ca.
@2FORCEFULL maybe this is a better way to ask my question, with a 210 Hallett running the Merc Racing Blue 377, would Rev 4 21 pitch, assuming I can spin it 5200 Rpm at wot be the same roughly on top, as spinning the Rev 4 23 p at 4800-4900 only with a better bite and bottom end snap with the Rev 4 21 pitch? Or would should I try the hill 5 blade 21p
I apologize in advance if I’m wordy, I wish I lived down south closer to the shops that know, and have experience. Not a lot of people in my area know much about anything except those damn wake boats.
The Hallett is currently spinning the rev 4 23 at 4800/4900 rpm wot trimmed up maybe 15/20%I can't comment on the Hill 5 blade, but I can comment on your Rev 4 21" vs 23" comparison. The Rev 4 has a LOT of blade area, which means more transmission of power engine power to boat motion. It also means it loads the motor more. I don't think the 377 will spin a Rev 4 to 5200 rpm. It might but in my hull (not a 210) it will not. If you could spin a Rev 4 21" to 5200 running a Rev 4 23" would load the motor to about 4400 rpm WOT. It would be a dog through out the range. My experience is to run a Rev 4 on the lower pitch end for best overall performance.
Thank you. I would definitely take u yoif I was closer.I have a 23p 5 blade cutting edge you could test. Its in needles though.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
I am interested in your findings. I have been thinking about doing a Hill 5 blade on my Hallett 255. I currently run a 26 Hill 4 blade and 26 Cutting Edge labbed prop.I just ordered the Hill 5 blade 21, ships tomorrow should have by Monday. Talked to Ron Hill the man, himself. Super personal.
he said to expect more rpm throughout, less slip, way more bottom and less bow rise when planing. And less porpoise at wot, and very likely more top speed. Who knew it was so easy lol. Idk, it’s worth a try, anyways. If that doesn’t work I’ll try the rev 4 21. Thanks all. I’ll share findings
I still have the Hill 23 P5 I got from you. Believe it or not, I still haven't had the chance to try it. Haven't used the boat much recently, due to my wife's medical issues. However, she is finally doing well and we are going to use it this year. I really want to try it after the Rev 23 I have on now.I have a 23p 5 blade cutting edge you could test. Its in needles though.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
I still have the Hill 23 P5 I got from you. Believe it or not, I still haven't had the chance to try it. Haven't used the boat much recently, due to my wife's medical issues. However, she is finally doing well and we are going to use it this year. I really want to try it after the Rev 23 I have on now.
I hope so. I have liked the Rev 23 the few times I have tried it. I am still trying to get some data on it. As soon as I do, I am going to go with the P5 and see what it does. I'll let you know. Might even be interested in the Cutting Edge 5 blade, if you're of a mind to part with it down the road.
I just ordered the Hill 5 blade 21, ships tomorrow should have by Monday. Talked to Ron Hill the man, himself. Super personal.
he said to expect more rpm throughout, less slip, way more bottom and less bow rise when planing. And less porpoise at wot, and very likely more top speed. Who knew it was so easy lol. Idk, it’s worth a try, anyways. If that doesn’t work I’ll try the rev 4 21. Thanks all. I’ll share findings
Shoot me a message if you decide to let the CE 5 blade go. I would like to talk to you about it.I might be selling the cutting edge or my bravo 24. I picked up a max 5 but havent used it enough to make sure i like it. So far its good.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
The 5 blade pleasure SS 21 pitch made my Hallett 210 go from a nice running boat with a rev 4 23 p to a rocket. It’s that big of an improvement. It can’t be understated - with the 377 blue motor it flies now, it’s on plane almost instantly and pulls hard to red line. No cavitation on turns or hard acceleration. Holeshot mid and top. All big time improved. I had heard that wasn’t possible, I’m here to say it is now. It takes off like a tournament ski boat nowI've been told a 5 blade can help cut down slip on a bigger less efficient hull. The 210 slip is already pretty low so not a lot of low hanging fruit.
My dad and uncle have 210s. Dad runs a labbed B1 26 and it's solid. Good on the big end will still pull up several skiers. Uncle runs a 24 and its a great performing prop as well.
The rev 4 23 was slower than the 21? What rpm did u turn the 23 at WOT?Thanks for the prop info. I too am running a Rev 4 23 coming up from a REV 4 21 that pulled way too many rpms. Haven't run the 23 but a couple of times and as you would predict, it was a bit slower, but not a lot, out of the hole. Midrange was a better. Didn't get to max it out yet. I do have a Hill P5 23 (thanks to RBcconst) that I have been wanting to try on my 270, but haven't had the chance. If you had that good a result, I think I am going to just test the 5 blade next time out and see what it does. I can always go back to the standby REV 4, if I don't like it.
Didn't get a chance to open up. Wife was with me and it got pretty rough for her, as she was still recovering from a couple of surgeries. It was just a little slower out of the hole and I expected that. The 21 launched that 270 on plane. The 23 did pretty well, just not as quick out of the hole as the 21.The rev 4 23 was slower than the 21? What rpm did u turn the 23 at WOT?
I would for sure try the the Hill 23p 5 blade. I would have tried one today if I had one. It was only about 70 out so I figure when it’s 100 degrees and I lose a few rpm I’m perfect. Best of luck. Would love to hear your results.Thanks for the prop info. I too am running a Rev 4 23 coming up from a REV 4 21 that pulled way too many rpms. Haven't run the 23 but a couple of times and as you would predict, it was a bit slower, but not a lot, out of the hole. Midrange was a better. Didn't get to max it out yet. I do have a Hill P5 23 (thanks to RBcconst) that I have been wanting to try on my 270, but haven't had the chance. If you had that good a result, I think I am going to just test the 5 blade next time out and see what it does. I can always go back to the standby REV 4, if I don't like it.
I was turning about 5300-5400 with my 21. I was hoping for about 5000-5100 max with the 23. I will try both of them next time out and see what it does.I would for sure try the the Hill 23p 5 blade. I would have tried one today if I had one. It was only about 70 out so I figure when it’s 100 degrees and I lose a few rpm I’m perfect. Best of luck. Would love to hear your results.
If you’re turning a rev 4 21 5300/5400, I imagine you’ll turn that 23 5 blade at least 5000 rpm, if not more. They spin. They’re only 14” diameter but man do they push that Hallett bottom with the extra blade slippage goes way down. You’re gonna go faster. Assuming yours is similar to the 210 bottomI was turning about 5300-5400 with my 21. I was hoping for about 5000-5100 max with the 23. I will try both of them next time out and see what it does.
Good to know. Funny, I had never really paid much attention to the bottom of my 270 until I had it lifted off last year, so I could refurb the trailer. On another note, I couldn't believe how scared I was watching them do this.If you’re turning a rev 4 21 5300, I promise you’ll turn that 23 5 blade 5000 rpm. They spin. They’re only 14” diameter but man do they push that Hallett bottom. Assuming yours is similar to the 210 bottom
did you ever try the hill 23p 5 blade???If you’re turning a rev 4 21 5300/5400, I imagine you’ll turn that 23 5 blade at least 5000 rpm, if not more. They spin. They’re only 14” diameter but man do they push that Hallett bottom with the extra blade slippage goes way down. You’re gonna go faster. Assuming yours is similar to the 210 bottom
I forget what motor and Hallett you have? The best I turned the 23 rev 4 this summer was 48-4900 rpm. The Hill 5 blade I turned 5300 and may have seen 5500 if I wanted to stay on it and keep trimming up. But I was so happy I backed off so I as but to break anything. No sign of any rev limiter coming on. It was spinning!!
No, not yet. Juts enjoyed the 21 p 5. You are reading my mind though. I keep meaning to send my bravo 1 22p to Chad, and trade him for a 23 p 5 blade pleasure. I really want to try it. I also want to try their 4 blade 23 pitch. The 21 Hill 5 blade pleasure is really nice. But I am definitely going yo try the 23 p hopefully to gain top speed and lower Rpm at 40-45 mph cruise. I can spin that 21 5 blade too hard. I had no idea how much outside temps effect the boats power and Rpms. You told me that when I started. I’ll let u know on the 23 5 blade. I’ll get one on next week. I also shoudl try the rev 4 23 again now that I know how to drive the boat better after a couple seasons, more trim and a little tab and let her go!did you ever try the hill 23p 5 blade???
Well, I did... The 23p Hill P5 would barely get to 4600 rpm and just shy of 60. I was pretty disappointed, but this wheel has a big vibration coming onto plane. It does level out some the faster you go. I pulled it off and sent it back to Hill twice and they checked it and re-balanced it, but it still has the vibration. I took it to the main prop guru here and he is checking it again. Hill was excellent to me and did all the work and didn't even charge me. I was very appreciative of that. They are a class business. I don't know what's wrong with it, but if my guy here can't fix it I may either send it back for a 21 P5 or just junk it. I think I really need a P5 21p to make it work.No, not yet. Juts enjoyed the 21 p 5. You are reading my mind though. I keep meaning to send my bravo 1 22p to Chad, and trade him for a 23 p 5 blade pleasure. I really want to try it. I also want to try their 4 blade 23 pitch. The 21 Hill 5 blade pleasure is really nice. But I am definitely going yo try the 23 p hopefully to gain top speed and lower Rpm at 40-45 mph cruise. I can spin that 21 5 blade too hard. I had no idea how much outside temps effect the boats power and Rpms. You told me that when I started. I’ll let u know on the 23 5 blade. I’ll get one on next week. I also shoudl try the rev 4 23 again now that I know how to drive the boat better after a couple seasons, more trim and a little tab and let her go!