Booshy
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2013
- Messages
- 222
- Reaction score
- 167
Is anyone running one of these? I looked but could not find a thread about them. Interested in knowing if there all that and a bag of chips?
Funny, but had a new battery installed in my 12' F150 EB recently. When I picked up the truck I found I was smoking and chirping the tires off the line ---WTF :thumbsup
Of course now it's returning back to a less responsive tip-in because after a few grins, I really don't want to be chirping tires all the time, so it's re-learned and returned to a more mild response.
Not only that, I don't want to be launching into the ass-end of the asshole in front of me who's still staring at his lap after the light turns green cuz he's preoccupied with texting. :grumble:
In my wife's Audi I can just change driving modes. What I am curious about is how this throttle control interacts with the vehicle's ability to learn your driving habits.
The only thing I really want, is when I mash the pedal, I want it to downshift now, not to act as if it's undecided. :thumbsdown
What you ask for | What you get |
5% throttle | 15% throttle |
10% throttle | 25% throttle |
20% throttle | 45% throttle |
30% throttle | 60% throttle |
50% throttle | 100% throttle |
They've been around for a long time. Basically what they do is more aggressively feed the throttle input signal to the ECU, so the ECU thinks you've asked for more throttle than you really have. This makes the vehicle respond to smaller inputs as if they were bigger inputs.
For instance:
What you ask for What you get 5% throttle 15% throttle 10% throttle 25% throttle 20% throttle 45% throttle 30% throttle 60% throttle 50% throttle 100% throttle
So it FEELS like you have more on tap, but actually, once you get to some point on the throttle where it's telling the ECU that you are at 100% throttle, from there on, there is no more. The ECU is already working as if the pedal was on the floor.
With drive-by-wire vehicles more the norm these days, this type of thing works. Any older vehicle with a cable controlled throttle will not be able to use something like this.
I have a new ram ecodiesel and the turbo lag is annoying as fuck, it goes nowhere and then it goes somewhere too fast when it does. It's impossible to be smooth with accelerating. I don't think the pedal dealio is it but turbo lag instead.
So, this thing is essentially a Sport button for vehicles not equipped with one?
Why not buy a programmer for a few hundred bucks more and get real hp out of it? Plus that will improve throttle response?
I would not use that item. Changing rate of throttle opening will fuck up stability control and any traction control systems, as well as ABS since they all depend on throttle input to determine if you are trying to steer through something vs reactionary brake/maneuvering.
I can't see how this would not fuck up your warranty, it's basically a tuner light....and in all modern vehicles that's a no no for warranty issues.
They've been around for a long time. Basically what they do is more aggressively feed the throttle input signal to the ECU, so the ECU thinks you've asked for more throttle than you really have. This makes the vehicle respond to smaller inputs as if they were bigger inputs.
So it FEELS like you have more on tap, but actually, once you get to some point on the throttle where it's telling the ECU that you are at 100% throttle, from there on, there is no more. The ECU is already working as if the pedal was on the floor.
With drive-by-wire vehicles more the norm these days, this type of thing works. Any older vehicle with a cable controlled throttle will not be able to use something like this.
Devil's advocate:
I'm not a fan.
I find cars are too "jumpy" as it is in relation to the throttle, all to make them feel fast on the test drive.
When you're trying to drive slow (like parking), and especially for off-roading, too much throttle response isn't always a good thing.
And it's not too hard to for me simply press on the gas a little bit more
So, this thing is essentially a Sport button for vehicles not equipped with one?
Pressing on the gas more does not do what the PC does. The PC makes the truck respond faster.
Its the electronic equivalent of moving the seat closer to the steering wheel and installing a lighter return spring on the carb
I thought this video from Sprint Booster gave a good representation of how these things work.
[video=youtube_https;1XVCYDNcwwY]https://youtu.be/1XVCYDNcwwY[/video]
I've never heard of anyone using a PC say this has happened to them ("there is no more" pedal). Show me please.
Holy cow. Please tell me what facts you have to base all this on!
ASE Master Tech, Bosch certified Master Tech, 30 years experience in the field, as well as having been an insurance inspector for Warranty for all makes and models, aftermarket insurance and factory.
Changing the throttle angle speed and it's related feedback to the BCM, ABS, SLP, TCU and other associated controllers that rely on SPECIFIC instantaneous details to perform their job is not something to play around with.
You can see EVERYTHING in the control units now, they save all related data like flight recorders. Any tampering will void your warranty.
Like others have said, there is no real performance gain to be had with this type of mod, it only tricks the throttle body into opening full throttle at half throttle.
Electro-mechanical devices like drive by wire throttle body has it's durability and lifespan predicted upon certain parameters, if you double them or triple them , then you are just burning them out faster.
Here's what I would like to know from somebody who is already using one of these -- Throttle Response Enhancement devices.
I'm not into street racing or stop light drag racing my F150 EB. So rapid launch times really isn't a priority. I appreciate linear throttle response for most of my activities.
However, one of my top priorities is the ability to promptly and rapidly pass on 2 lanes roads when required. Passing at speed, say 60 +MPH is never a problem, but can prove frustrating if you get bogged down to 30 or 40, get your shot, mash the peddle and the ECU seems to start a downshifting debate --- "which gear, ho hum, 4th, well maybe 3rd, ok, well I guess I'll shift now, but gotta keep my EPA numbers up there", that drives me friggin insane.
Point is, my frustration isn't with throttle response it's with transmission response. I've read nothing in regards to how these devices alter shift patterns or the response time of the ECU in making it's determination.
What say ye ?
Here's what I would like to know from somebody who is already using one of these -- Throttle Response Enhancement devices.
I'm not into street racing or stop light drag racing my F150 EB. So rapid launch times really isn't a priority. I appreciate linear throttle response for most of my activities.
However, one of my top priorities is the ability to promptly and rapidly pass on 2 lanes roads when required. Passing at speed, say 60 +MPH is never a problem, but can prove frustrating if you get bogged down to 30 or 40, get your shot, mash the peddle and the ECU seems to start a downshifting debate --- "which gear, ho hum, 4th, well maybe 3rd, ok, well I guess I'll shift now, but gotta keep my EPA numbers up there", that drives me friggin insane.
Point is, my frustration isn't with throttle response it's with transmission response. I've read nothing in regards to how these devices alter shift patterns or the response time of the ECU in making it's determination.
What say ye ?
Here's what I would like to know from somebody who is already using one of these -- Throttle Response Enhancement devices.
I'm not into street racing or stop light drag racing my F150 EB. So rapid launch times really isn't a priority. I appreciate linear throttle response for most of my activities.
However, one of my top priorities is the ability to promptly and rapidly pass on 2 lanes roads when required. Passing at speed, say 60 +MPH is never a problem, but can prove frustrating if you get bogged down to 30 or 40, get your shot, mash the peddle and the ECU seems to start a downshifting debate --- "which gear, ho hum, 4th, well maybe 3rd, ok, well I guess I'll shift now, but gotta keep my EPA numbers up there", that drives me friggin insane.
Point is, my frustration isn't with throttle response it's with transmission response. I've read nothing in regards to how these devices alter shift patterns or the response time of the ECU in making it's determination.
What say ye ?
BINGO! That is probably the only thing that bugs me about our JGC. Even with sport mode on the throttle delay was unbearable. Could i get the v6 tuned? Probably. Will i? Absolutely not. I have the personality that cant leave anything alone which is the reason i went with a V6 instead of the V8...
I had a Subaru STI once.....yeaaa never want to go down that endless mod road ever again lol.
The interesting thing about these throttle controllers is, the more i read into them, the more they remind me of the throttle profiles i was able to choose on my rc trucks. The throttle curves in relation to the trigger position is almost identical. Watching that youtube vid kind of convinced me.
You need an engine and transmission tune. Drive it in tow/haul mode in lieu of that.
A tune is the ultimate solution.
These pedal commanders are just a gimmick that move the throttle blade more for a given pedal position. The car is not any faster.
When time allows for preparation, Tow-Haul or I can use manual mode to drop a couple of gears, but there's always those times when you want and need it NOW, when the wait gets frustrating, occasionally SCARY :eek
I've been down the tuner route with other more sporty vehicles, but I've been hesitant to screw with my otherwise problem free (so far, knock on wood) trusty truck. In the past going that route I've always sacrificed one thing to gain another. Later when the tuner is questioned, the response is either --- "yup, that's normal" or "Damn, first time I've heard of that" which leads to tossing more $$ at it
Getting good feedback from others is the tricky part, everybody loves to brag about how awesome it turned out, without elaborating on any associated negatives.
The tune on the f150 EB solves all the delayed throttle response and transmission finding a year tomorrow problems. I step on the gas at 40 it shift hard and goes no delay about it. Tunes improve throttle response by doing the same thing while actually adding power. Why not do one. This gimic is stupid!
Oh I wasn't considering the throttle response booster --- I have no complaints with my more linear throttle modulation. My leg is well practiced at mashing the go pedal :thumbsup
But to clarify, several of you have suggested "A Tune" for throttle, trans shifting, or both. Were you suggesting taking it to a tuner or buying and installing a tuner ? Or both ?
When I had my Whippled Ford 5.0 Miata I had a great tuner, right up until the FBI hauled him off for murdering two previous wives :yikes
SBMech -- Does the "Drive it like you stole it" performance mode require 200 miles of spirited driving, or does it change modes based on more immediate driving style ?
Pressing on the gas more does not do what the PC does. The PC makes the truck respond faster.
No, that's exactly what it does. Making the throttle respond "faster" is impossible as it would have to see into the future and anticipate you pressing the throttle before you actually did. And removing the delay from the PCM is not possible without reflashing the system. It does exactly what STV_Keith described.
I don't know why the OEMs have so much throttle attack delay built into their software, it's one of the dumbest things in my opinion. They dampen the output way too much and it causes dangerous situations when you are trying to make left yields or pulling out into traffic. True drive by wire is capable of processing and outputting pedal position to throttle position faster than an actual cable is, there is a reason formula 1 has been using it for decades. Not to mention all of the other additional benefits DBW has, including simplicity of installation.
No, that's exactly what it does. Making the throttle respond "faster" is impossible as it would have to see into the future and anticipate you pressing the throttle before you actually did. And removing the delay from the PCM is not possible without reflashing the system. It does exactly what STV_Keith described.
I don't know why the OEMs have so much throttle attack delay built into their software, it's one of the dumbest things in my opinion. They dampen the output way too much and it causes dangerous situations when you are trying to make left yields or pulling out into traffic. True drive by wire is capable of processing and outputting pedal position to throttle position faster than an actual cable is, there is a reason formula 1 has been using it for decades. Not to mention all of the other additional benefits DBW has, including simplicity of installation.
No but where has sbmech been?