WELCOME TO RIVER DAVES PLACE

AI And Classwork...

monkeyswrench

To The Rescue!
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
36,918
Reaction score
108,339
Talking to a teacher, and they were saying that so many students use AI for reports, that there is now a program they run the reports through. An AI detector if you will.
So, I ask why they can't use AI, it's pretty much like another tool, like spell check and such.
"It's essentially cheating. They aren't putting in the effort to do the job themselves."

Me, being a bit, well, myself:
"So, them using a computer to write it is cheating, but you using the same technology to find out isn't?"

Yes, I may have received the "don't be an asshole look" from my wife...but I think I made my point.

Welcome to the future!
 
You got the look from your wife. . . ..

What was the look on the teachers face?

I'm guessing they called for an Administrator and they had the same look as the teacher.


Hummmmuna, hummana, hummana
 
Talking to a teacher, and they were saying that so many students use AI for reports, that there is now a program they run the reports through. An AI detector if you will.
So, I ask why they can't use AI, it's pretty much like another tool, like spell check and such.
"It's essentially cheating. They aren't putting in the effort to do the job themselves."

Me, being a bit, well, myself:
"So, them using a computer to write it is cheating, but you using the same technology to find out isn't?"

Yes, I may have received the "don't be an asshole look" from my wife...but I think I made my point.

Welcome to the future!

I agree with the teacher, they should not be able to use AI for reports, essays, ect. There are AI programs that could write the whole report. Give it the book name, persay, or key words and it will write you a summery(report)

That's like when we were in school we couldnt have a calculator on our desk during a math test. Kind of the same theory.. jmo and you know the teacher probably had to use a calculator to figure it out themselves🤣
 
I agree with the teacher, they should not be able to use AI for reports, essays, ect. There are AI programs that could write the whole report. Give it the book name, persay, or key words and it will write you a summery(report)

That's like when we were in school we couldnt have a calculator on our desk during a math test. Kind of the same theory.. jmo and you know the teacher probably had to use a calculator to figure it out themselves🤣

Only once though. Then they handed out the same test over 10 thousand times! 🤣
 
I agree with the teacher, they should not be able to use AI for reports, essays, ect. There are AI programs that could write the whole report. Give it the book name, persay, or key words and it will write you a summery(report)

That's like when we were in school we couldnt have a calculator on our desk during a math test. Kind of the same theory.. jmo and you know the teacher probably had to use a calculator to figure it out themselves🤣
If you ran your post through AI it would have corrected your spelling error. ECT.

Just messing you. I used to sneak a calculator. I wasnt a kook, never had a calculator watch. Maybe I should have, that D average was something to be proud of. 😁
 
I agree with the teacher, using AI for reports, is not researching and learning about the subject, it's simply printing up someone else's information you don't even have to read or learn. Feel the same way about computers and calculators for tests. Students can no longer do simple math in their heads anymore.
At some point we will rely solely on AI to develop advancements as people will not know how to think and do things on their own.
 
If you ran your post through AI it would have corrected your spelling error. ECT.

Just messing you. I used to sneak a calculator. I wasnt a kook, never had a calculator watch. Maybe I should have, that D average was something to be proud of. 😁

English/spelling was never my strong suit we didnt have spell check back then🤷🏻‍♂️😩 but I bet you deciphered all of my mistakes😉

🤣🤣
 
I agree with the teacher, they should not be able to use AI for reports, essays, ect. There are AI programs that could write the whole report. Give it the book name, persay, or key words and it will write you a summery(report)

That's like when we were in school we couldnt have a calculator on our desk during a math test. Kind of the same theory.. jmo and you know the teacher probably had to use a calculator to figure it out themselves🤣
Yeah, because you wouldn’t always have a calculator available. Now we not only have calculators available, we have a connected computer on hand at all times.
 
They should just copy and paste from google searches like the old days.

Had an economics class that this worked backwards. The teacher used someone else's tests and someone from class sent a group email telling everyone as they googled part of it and it came right up.

Teacher found out towards end of semester and was going to fail everyone. I was pissed because I did not go that route, I wanted to know the material. I told her if she failed everyone I would report her for plagiarism and even though I passed, I retook that class because she was a lousy teacher. Macro economics.
 
Last edited:
As a kid in the 80's I would sometimes copy off of encyclopedias, I was fortunate enough to have a Jr Britannica set that my dad bought at a garage sale. It didn't matter though, I still learned the subject because I had to read the text while typing it on a word processer....I couldn't just copy and paste. Something tells me AI isn't the same thing...
 
I actually asked how the "AI detector" worked. Not the computer end of it, but what it did...I'm not technologically advanced. I guess the "papers" are now assignments turned in as some sort of file online to the teacher. The teacher runs the paper through the snitch program, and then it spits out a percentage of "how AI" the assignment is. I was curious, because AI in it's current state uses the web as it's encyclopedia, and coughs up what would be the most accepted or plausible response. That said, the students use the web as their encyclopedia too. This means there should always be a percentage of AI content, because the sources are the same. That said, to "pass" the AI detector, I think they said you couldn't have more than 20 or 25% "AI generated content". Actually, pretty interesting from a technology standpoint.

Luckily the teacher in question was good natured about the comment. I think my use of the word "Ironic" made sense to them after a bit of thought. It also helps that this was just a sidebar conversation, and not the the main discussion.

I'm thinking I need to learn to use AI. It sounds a lot smarter than me...it can figure out answers to questions I don't know I need to ask. That part is cool.
 
I actually asked how the "AI detector" worked. Not the computer end of it, but what it did...I'm not technologically advanced. I guess the "papers" are now assignments turned in as some sort of file online to the teacher. The teacher runs the paper through the snitch program, and then it spits out a percentage of "how AI" the assignment is. I was curious, because AI in it's current state uses the web as it's encyclopedia, and coughs up what would be the most accepted or plausible response. That said, the students use the web as their encyclopedia too. This means there should always be a percentage of AI content, because the sources are the same. That said, to "pass" the AI detector, I think they said you couldn't have more than 20 or 25% "AI generated content". Actually, pretty interesting from a technology standpoint.

Luckily the teacher in question was good natured about the comment. I think my use of the word "Ironic" made sense to them after a bit of thought. It also helps that this was just a sidebar conversation, and not the the main discussion.

I'm thinking I need to learn to use AI. It sounds a lot smarter than me...it can figure out answers to questions I don't know I need to ask. That part is cool.

A little over a year ago I thought...

I either have to get ahead of this thing, or get behind it! I made the decision to figure out how it works.

Watched a TED talk by the guy that created OpenAI. That's the parent company of ChatGPT. Pretty interesting on learning how it works.

Then, put the ChatGPT app on my phone and started asking it stupid questions...

Unlike RDP, it never gives you a smart azz answer! It actually is pretty cool.

😎

 
The last three generations of high school students haven't had the pleasure of writing a two page English composition in cursive script with a blue ink ball point pen on college ruled paper.

And mistakes weren't allowed. If one screwed up, even on the last sentence, the page had to be rewritten.

Bunch of pussies couldn't make it back in the day. Now turn down that rap shit and pull up your pants!
 
The last three generations of high school students haven't had the pleasure of writing a two page English composition in cursive script with a blue ink ball point pen on college ruled paper.

And mistakes weren't allowed. If one screwed up, even on the last sentence, the page had to be rewritten.

Bunch of pussies couldn't make it back in the day. Now turn down that rap shit and pull up your pants!
My 16yo, the wrestling monkey, is one of few at the high school I believe that can read and write in cursive. His friends think it's weird he knows how :oops:

I graduated HS in '95. I had a mix of written, and typed essays. All were drafted with a #2 pencil, then either copied in blue or black ink, or typed on an actual typewriter. I didn't have a computer until 2001, and a printer a little after. Spell check was cool, but being able to proof and make changes without WhiteOut or re-writing was great!
 
The last three generations of high school students haven't had the pleasure of writing a two page English composition in cursive script with a blue ink ball point pen on college ruled paper.

And mistakes weren't allowed. If one screwed up, even on the last sentence, the page had to be rewritten.

Bunch of pussies couldn't make it back in the day. Now turn down that rap shit and pull up your pants!

A ball point pen? I still remember using a flair tip with an ink well writing on tree bark by the light of a candle.
 
Pfft...

I used a stone tablet with a hammer and a chisel!

In the dark! 😁

Is it true that you used to drag yore women's around by the hair rather then the ankles so they wouldn't fill up with gravel?
 
The primary way the AI tool detects the use of AI in a submitted assignment is word choice and writing style. K-12 students aren't exactly Rhodes scholars so the presence of words that they normally wouldn't use or a sentence structure that is not characteristic of basic English skills can be detected.

Additionally, AI writing has some quirks that so far are detectable. One of them so far is the use if the word “likely”, it comes up frequently.

And yes, there is no paper anymore. Everything is submitted via online classroom portals, graded electronically and returned electronically. Rarely is anything printed out. Chromebooks which are the common device in schools no longer support easy printing.
 
A ball point pen? I still remember using a flair tip with an ink well writing on tree bark by the light of a candle
… When I was in the sixth grade, our desks which were in four neat little rows… Still had the hole in the wood desktop for an inkwell… that was 1956… I have no idea when those desks were manufactured🤷🏽‍♀️..
 
I’m thinking that 10 years from now, or probably sooner, education is not going to be anywhere close to recognizable to what it is today. Teacher’s union members better learn how to landscape or do OF…
 
I’m thinking that 10 years from now, or probably sooner, education is not going to be anywhere close to recognizable to what it is today. Teacher’s union members better learn how to landscape or do OF…

When I was in college a professor figured that one day most of the classes would be done online. He was right, in that they could be. Think about cost savings. Not having to maintain buildings, 1 teacher for each class. No parking lots or commuting. Campus dorms, all gone. Why not???????? Some classes are hands on in person, so combine them with trade schools and be done with them.

Not sure how this fits in, but I barely earned enough credits to finish my freshman year in HS. 20+ years later I passed the GED test after taking one class for math. Did not know how to divide or multiply fractions.
 
It isn't using AI so much as it is the plagiarism aspect. 30 years ago when I was in High School you could reference material you used writing papers but it had to be annotated and the entire paper could not have been lifted from somewhere else.

My HS age daughter has been told that AI is not verboten, but it is a tool to be used, just like encyclopedias, Google searches and good old fashioned research was in the past.

And yes, they (the teachers) have a tool that is run on the student's papers that vets the work for the amount of AI that was utilized.
 
Talking to a teacher, and they were saying that so many students use AI for reports, that there is now a program they run the reports through. An AI detector if you will.
So, I ask why they can't use AI, it's pretty much like another tool, like spell check and such.
"It's essentially cheating. They aren't putting in the effort to do the job themselves."

Me, being a bit, well, myself:
"So, them using a computer to write it is cheating, but you using the same technology to find out isn't?"

Yes, I may have received the "don't be an asshole look" from my wife...but I think I made my point.

Welcome to the future!
Monkey, you are correct of course, but the whole point is to make you think. Just like math, using a calculator in school..why? One should be able to do simple math in their head. Buying something and figuring out your change owed before the cashier can type it in.

Not wanting to think IMO has helped to us get where we are at in the country today. Believe what you are told or read in the newspaper, don't bother to research anything it may run counter to what you were just told.
 
Inadvernently they are doing vaulable homework, just not in the manner it was originally intended. They're learning to wriite prompts which is/will be the future for mankind.
 
Back
Top