For what it's worth here's my story. Boat is a mach 26 with a whipped 500efi 725hp. I am religious when it comes to drive oil and maintenance. I baby it out of the hole, easy on and easy off the throttle. This has been my experience and I'm going SCX and wish I would've from the beginning. I'll give up 10mph for reliability at this point.
Brand New XR - 40hours Upper Broken clutch shaft
New Imco SC - 45 hours Upper Broke a tooth on the forward gear and twisted the input shaft which tore the splines on the engine coupler.
Imco SC built by MMW - 20 hours Upper twisted and broke input shaft probably need another new engine coupler and gearset destroyed. This just happened last weekend.
I have a Imco SC lower that has been through all of these uppers. Aaron at Max Machine Work has been great. He has worked with me thru all of this and has been more than fair. I definitely do not blame him for any of it. I just believe if you are putting more than 600hp and 600ft lbs to these Mercury gears it's a ticking time bomb. The upgrades that they do definitely work because none of their parts or shafts have broken. The gears are and will always be the downfall. The guy behind the throttles has a lot to do with it and maybe that's the case with me but I accept it. It is what it is and if you wanna go 100mph with bigger power you have to be willing to pay the price. I tell everyone Bayliner makes a real reliable boat, if that's what you're into